Methodology

How we score B2B emails

Every email in a CASE teardown gets four scores from 1 to 10: subject line hook,visual/copy hierarchy, psychological trigger and CTA clarity. The average decides the format. Sequences scoring 6 or higher become best practice teardowns. Lower scorers with a clear lesson become what not to do teardowns.

1 Subject line hook

Would the right reader open it from a crowded inbox? We look at specificity, curiosity, relevance to the reader's job, and how the subject line and preheader work together.

  • Scores high: Specific, about the reader's problem, and backed up by the preheader.
  • Scores low: Generic, all about the sender, or a clickbait promise the body does not keep.

2 Visual / copy hierarchy

Can a reader skimming for five seconds get the point? We look at the first line, scannable structure, length for the job, and whether design helps or gets in the way.

  • Scores high: One idea per email, the point in the first two lines, easy to skim on a phone.
  • Scores low: A wall of text, three competing messages, or a hero image doing all the work.

3 Psychological trigger

Why would someone act? We name the lever (loss aversion, social proof, reciprocity, commitment, curiosity, timing) and judge whether it fits the reader's stage.

  • Scores high: A clear lever that fits where the reader is in the journey.
  • Scores low: No reason to act now, or pressure that does not match the relationship.

4 CTA clarity

Is the next step obvious, low-friction and worth it? We look at the number of CTAs, the button copy, and what happens after the click.

  • Scores high: One primary action, phrased as the value the reader gets.
  • Scores low: Several competing links, "Learn more" buttons, or a big ask too early.

Use it on your own sends

Score your next email before it goes out. Anything under 6 on a single criterion is your first A/B test. Every score in a teardown quotes the line from the email that earned it, so you can see the reasoning.